Skip to content

Tasting feedback

Feedback collects what people tell you about your beer. You print a card for the bottles you hand out, whoever gets one sends you a scoresheet from their phone, and every sheet shows up on one page alongside the batch it belongs to. The sheets a competition mailed back go on the same page, read from a photograph.

You get there from Feedback in the batch header, next to Brew day. When sheets have arrived that you haven’t read yet, the button shows how many, and opening the page clears the count the way an inbox does.

The Feedback page for a batch, collecting and waiting: the Collect panel with its buttons, the summary before anything has been scored, and the list saying where sheets will land.The Feedback page for a batch, collecting and waiting: the Collect panel with its buttons, the summary before anything has been scored, and the list saying where sheets will land.

Check the beers you are pouring on the batches page, with the same checkbox each recipe carries for a shopping list, and press Print tasting cards. The button counts what you have checked, and the Packaged and Conditioning chips narrow the log to the beers you can actually pour for somebody. The sheet is two columns, six cards to a page, on A4 or US Letter, with a dashed line where the scissors go. Your browser’s own print dialog is what puts it on paper, or saves it as a PDF. The Feedback page has the same action for one beer, under Print a card.

A card shows the beer’s name, its style and its strength, a code to scan, and the same link printed underneath for anyone whose phone camera won’t cooperate. We don’t put anything else on it. Tasters need the style so they can judge the beer against it, and the strength because they’re about to drink it. Nothing about your grain bill goes on the card.

One tasting card: the beer's name and style line, a QR code beside the invitation to scan it, and the link printed underneath.One tasting card: the beer's name and style line, a QR code beside the invitation to scan it, and the link printed underneath.

The link keeps working for as long as you leave it on, so a card tied to a bottle in July still works in November. Stop collecting turns it off, and anyone who scans that card afterward sees a message saying the link has been turned off, instead of a form that goes nowhere.

A blend prints the same way, from Print a card on its own Feedback page, and its card says Blend and the blend’s strength where a batch’s card shows its style.

A journal prints the same way too, for a cider, a mead or a hot sauce, from Print a card on the journal’s Feedback page. A journal has no style, so its card shows the strength from the newest ABV calculator on the page, and leaves that line blank when the page doesn’t have one.

The print page has one checkbox, Let tasters see what is in it. If you leave it unchecked, the form tasters open from the code shows the beer’s name, its style and its strength, and nothing about how you made it. Check it and we add a link to every card on the sheet.

What that link opens depends on the beer. For a batch it’s the recipe as you brewed it, the copy the batch saved on brew day, so editing the recipe afterward won’t change anything for somebody with a bottle you gave away in July. For a blend it’s the blending session, which shows the beers that went into it, anything you added with them, and the finished blend’s numbers. A blend wasn’t brewed from a recipe, so the session is what shows what’s in the glass.

For a journal it’s the journal’s shared page, which shows every block you haven’t hidden, including photos and files. It’s worth checking the page before you check the box.

The printed card and the code look the same either way. The checkbox only changes what the form shows, so if you change your mind, uncheck it and print the sheet again.

If you would rather stick the code on the bottle than tie a card to it, open the batch and press Print labels. The page you land on shows an Avery 5520, thirty weatherproof labels of one inch by two and five-eighths, and the same layout as the 5160. Pick a beer, tap the labels it goes on, add another beer if the sheet is shared, and print. Labels you leave blank stay blank, so you can put a part-used sheet back in the drawer. Next time, tap the labels that are still on it.

The Print labels page: the beer's chip above a sketch of the Avery sheet, seven of its thirty labels tapped and tinted with the beer's name, and the rest left blank.The Print labels page: the beer's chip above a sketch of the Avery sheet, seven of its thirty labels tapped and tinted with the beer's name, and the rest left blank.

Print at 100% with no margins, on US Letter. Each label shows the beer’s name, the recipe if it’s named differently, the style and the ABV, and the same code as the tasting card, so whatever people send ends up on the batch either way.

Print labels on a blend opens the same sheet, and a blend’s label says Blend and its strength where a batch’s shows its style. You can put both on one sheet: Add another lists your batches and your blends under headings of their own.

A journal’s Print labels opens the same sheet again, and its label shows the journal’s name, the strength when the page has an ABV calculator, and the code. Journals get a heading of their own under Add another too, so a cider and the beer you brewed beside it can share a sheet.

Scanning a card opens a short page with your beer’s name on it and nothing else of yours. Tasters don’t need an account or to sign in, and we never ask who they are. The name field is optional and starts blank, and if they leave it empty, the sheet reaches you as Anonymous. What they write goes to you and to nobody else.

Quick is what opens first, for the friend at a club meeting with a glass in one hand. It is a slider from 0 to 50 with BJCP’s own word for the number beside it as they drag, one line saying what the ends of the scale mean, the eighteen descriptor chips with a plain-English hint on each of them, one question (“What stood out, and what would you change?”), and their name if they want to give it. The score stays empty until the taster moves the slider, so we only save a score somebody picked.

Full sheet is the 2021 BJCP sheet, a tap away for a judge or for anybody who wants to take their time. It has name, BJCP ID and rank, bottle inspection, the five sections each with a score and a comment, the same descriptor chips, the three 1 to 5 rows with the sheet’s own words at each end, and closing notes. We add up the total as the sections are filled in.

Either way, sending ends with one sentence saying the sheet has been passed on. If somebody comes back to the same card later, we tell them they’ve already sent one and offer the form again, so they can send another sheet after a second glass.

A journal’s form is the same two sheets with the beer taken out of them. The five sections and the fifty points are all still there, because aroma, flavor and the rest are what anyone tasting anything gets asked. The eighteen descriptor chips are gone, and so are the BJCP ID, the rank, the bottle inspection and stylistic accuracy. Those chips name faults in beer, and they don’t make sense for a cider or a hot sauce.

Add a competition sheet takes what came back from a competition, either a photograph of the paper or the PDF the organizers emailed, up to twelve pages at a time. Your device turns each page into an image before anything is uploaded, so what we store is a legible picture of the sheet a judge actually wrote on.

We then read it and fill in a scoresheet from it, with the section scores, the total as written, the descriptors that were checked, the comments, and the date on the sheet. If one scan has several judges on it, you get several sheets, all linked to the same pages. Reading a scan uses one of your monthly assistant messages. We store the pages before we read them, so if a read goes wrong, you can try again without retaking the photograph.

The three 1 to 5 rows are the one thing we don’t read. A checkmark in one of five small boxes is too small to read reliably from a photograph, so we leave it blank and ask you to tap the box the judge marked when you review the sheet.

A sheet we read from a photograph stays a draft until you confirm it. Its row shows Check this reading, which opens the page on one side and the sheet on the other, with anything we were unsure of marked for you. Correct anything that’s wrong and press That’s right, and it joins the other sheets. If the reading came out so badly that starting over is quicker than fixing it, Read again has another go. Until you confirm a sheet, we tell the assistant it’s a draft, and it mentions that before relying on it.

The top of the page counts your competition sheets, tasting sheets, and your own. Under What people found is the average score from each of those three sources, the descriptors people checked most often with the number of times each was checked, and, when two or more judges have scored the beer, how far apart they were. Two judges agreeing tells you more than either one alone, so we show you the spread.

The sheets themselves are listed newest first, and the chips above them filter to Competition, Collected or Yours. Each row opens into the whole sheet: every section score, every comment, the descriptors, and the taster’s name where they gave one.

A blend has its own Feedback page, opened from Feedback in the blend’s header, and it works the same way for the blend’s sheets and scans. Two things only apply to batches, so the blend’s page leaves them out. There’s no Yours chip, because you write your own tasting on a batch, and no Ask the assistant what to change, because that suggests changes to a recipe and a blend doesn’t have one.

A journal’s Feedback page, opened from Feedback in the journal’s header, is the same as a blend’s and leaves out the same two things for the same reasons.

We send one email a night, only on nights somebody wrote to you, saying how many sheets arrived and linking to the batch, blend or journal they’re about. We send one a night instead of one per sheet because a club meeting can produce thirty sheets in two hours, and thirty emails would be enough to make anyone turn them off. Sheets you have already opened in the app are not emailed about, since you have seen them.

The email gives the count and a link, and never names the beer, because people read email in places you can’t control. The switch is in Settings → Notifications, called Tell me when tasting sheets arrive. It starts on, since printing a card is a good sign you want to hear back.

Beside the batch name at the top of the page, Ask the assistant what to change opens the assistant on this batch and asks it to read the sheets. It weighs a judge’s sheet above a quick one and two judges agreeing above either, keeps “not to style” apart from “not well made” because they call for different advice, and reads each descriptor as a pointer at a part of your brew day: butter at fermentation temperature, green apple at beer pulled off the yeast early, stale paper at how it was packaged. Then it looks at what you actually measured, and if your log is missing a reading that would settle the question, it tells you which one. Each answer spends one of your monthly assistant messages.

Printing cards, reading competition sheets and this page come with both paid plans, Brewmaster and Beerwright. We store the sheets on our server instead of on your device, which is why this page needs a connection when most of the app doesn’t.

Tasters can always use the form on the card. A card already on a bottle keeps working whatever happens to your subscription, and we keep every sheet that arrives until you’re back on a plan that includes this page. If your plan lapses, you can’t print new cards, read scans or open this page, but nothing changes for your tasters.

Something wrong on this page? Tell us.